Quick answer: The Chevy Silverado 1500 is the slightly more reliable truck — it wins J.D. Power’s dependability study, has fewer recalls (91 vs 107 over 2018–2026) and fewer owner complaints per truck sold. But the gap is small: for a brand-new 2026 truck, both score 86/100 from J.D. Power, and Consumer Reports rates the F-150 a touch higher. Buying used, the model year and engine matter far more than the badge.
Verdict
Winner: Chevrolet Silverado 1500 — narrowly. It takes J.D. Power’s dependability studies (ranked 1st in 2025, 2nd in 2026 vs. tied 3rd), has fewer recalls (91 vs. 107 from 2018–2026) and fewer owner complaints (3.8 vs. 5.4 per 10,000 sold), and costs less to repair (~$714 vs. ~$788 a year). Buy the F-150 instead if you are buying new: the 2026 trucks tie at 86/100 on J.D. Power, and Consumer Reports rates the F-150 a touch higher (43 vs. 40).
Quick read: the Silverado wins the long-term, real-world measures; the F-150 wins the forward-looking forecasts. Buying used, the model year and engine matter far more than the badge.
Scored comparison
| Reliability measure | Ford F-150 | Chevy Silverado 1500 | Edge |
|---|---|---|---|
| J.D. Power 2025 dependability | 6 — Not in top 3 | 9 — Ranked 1st | Silverado |
| J.D. Power 2026 dependability | 7 — Tied 3rd | 8 — 2nd | Silverado |
| J.D. Power quality & reliability score | 8 — 86/100 | 8 — 86/100 | Tie |
| Consumer Reports predicted reliability | 7 — 43/100 | 6 — 40/100 | F-150 |
| Consumer Reports Top Pick | 9 — Yes | 5 — No | F-150 |
| Longevity (iSeeCars, chance of 250,000 miles) | 7 — 15.8% | 8 — 18.8% | Silverado |
| Recalls, 2018–2026 | 6 — 107 | 8 — 91 | Silverado |
| Owner complaints per 10,000 sold | 7 — 5.4 | 9 — 3.8 | Silverado |
| Average annual repair cost (RepairPal) | 7 — ~$788 | 8 — ~$714 | Silverado |
Scores are our 1–10 reading of the figures already in this article; they are not separate test results.
How we rank / Sources & method
We compare J.D. Power’s Vehicle Dependability and Initial Quality studies, Consumer Reports’ predicted reliability scores, iSeeCars’ longevity study of more than 402 million vehicles, NHTSA recall and complaint records, and RepairPal repair costs. This is a reliability comparison, so the scores cover reliability evidence only — there are no price, fuel-economy or towing scores here. Prices are starting MSRP excluding destination unless stated.
Data as of: November 2026 (published November 7, 2026).
The Ford F-150 and the Chevrolet Silverado 1500 are the two best-selling trucks in America. The F-150 has been the best-selling truck in the US for 49 consecutive years, with the Silverado chasing it in second place for most of that time. But when you are spending $40,000 or more on a truck you plan to keep for a decade, sales charts do not matter. What matters is which one stays out of the shop. Below is what the data says: J.D. Power dependability rankings, Consumer Reports predicted reliability, iSeeCars longevity odds, NHTSA recall and complaint records, and real repair costs.
Ford F-150 vs Chevy Silverado Reliability at a Glance
| Reliability measure | Ford F-150 | Chevy Silverado 1500 | Winner |
|---|---|---|---|
| J.D. Power 2025 Vehicle Dependability Study (large light-duty pickup) | Not in top 3 | Ranked 1st | Silverado |
| J.D. Power 2026 Vehicle Dependability Study | Tied 3rd | 2nd | Silverado |
| J.D. Power 2026 Quality & Reliability score | 86/100 | 86/100 | Tie |
| Consumer Reports 2026 predicted reliability | 43/100 | 40/100 | F-150 |
| Consumer Reports 2026 Top Pick | Yes | No | F-150 |
| iSeeCars chance of reaching 250,000 miles | 15.8% | 18.8% | Silverado |
| Recalls, 2018–2026 model years | 107 | 91 | Silverado |
| Owner complaints per 10,000 sold | 5.4 | 3.8 | Silverado |
| Average annual repair cost (RepairPal) | ~$788 | ~$714 | Silverado |
The Silverado wins most long-term, real-world measures; the F-150 wins the forward-looking Consumer Reports forecast.
What J.D. Power Says About F-150 vs Silverado Reliability
J.D. Power runs two studies that matter here. The Vehicle Dependability Study (VDS) surveys owners of three-year-old vehicles about the problems they actually experienced, while the Initial Quality Study (IQS) tracks problems in the first 90 days.
In the 2025 VDS, the Chevrolet Silverado 1500 ranked highest in the Large Light Duty Pickup segment; the Ford F-150 did not rank among the top three. In the 2025 IQS, the two tied for the top spot — so early build quality is a wash, but after three years of real use, Silverado owners reported fewer problems. The 2026 VDS, covering 2023 model-year trucks, tells the same story: the Silverado ranked second among full-size pickups, behind only the Ram 1500, while the F-150 tied for third with the GMC Sierra 1500.
For brand-new trucks, the gap disappears: J.D. Power gives both the 2026 F-150 and the 2026 Silverado 1500 a Quality and Reliability score of 86 out of 100. The Silverado edges ahead on overall score (83/100 vs 82/100) mainly because owners rated its dealership experience higher, not because the truck itself breaks down less.
What Consumer Reports Says
Consumer Reports tells the opposite story, because it measures something different: its predicted reliability score forecasts how a new model is likely to hold up, blending historical data with owner surveys of nearly 400,000 vehicles.
For 2026, Consumer Reports gives the Ford F-150 a predicted reliability score of 43 out of 100, slightly ahead of the Chevrolet Silverado 1500 at 40 out of 100. The F-150 PowerBoost hybrid does better still at 49 out of 100, the highest-scoring full-size truck in Consumer Reports’ 2026 data, and the F-150 earned a Consumer Reports Top Pick for 2026 — the first full-size pickup to do so since 2019. The Silverado did not earn the recommendation.
Some honest context: a score in the low 40s means both trucks are predicted to be less reliable than the average new car. Consumer Reports ties much of the Silverado’s weak score to its V8 powertrain — its lowest possible rating in seven of the past ten years — and notes owner reports of electrical issues, including lights, gauges, USB ports, and automatic headlights.
So the two biggest reliability authorities disagree — J.D. Power’s three-year ownership data favors the Silverado, while Consumer Reports’ forecast favors the F-150. These trucks are genuinely close, and your choice should come down to the specific engine and model year, not the badge.
How Long Will Each Truck Last?
A reliability score is abstract. Mileage is not. The question most buyers really mean is: will this truck still be running at 200,000 miles?
iSeeCars studied more than 402 million vehicles to answer exactly that. Its latest longevity study found that the Chevrolet Silverado 1500 has an 18.8% chance of reaching 250,000 miles, while the Ford F-150 has a 15.8% chance. The average vehicle manages only 8.6%, so both trucks are nearly twice as likely as the average car to hit a quarter of a million miles.
Both trucks can last 200,000 to 300,000 miles with disciplined maintenance — regular oil changes, transmission service, and fixing small problems before they grow. The Silverado has a small statistical edge, but either truck rewards an owner who maintains it and punishes one who does not. See our roundup of the most reliable cars for 2026 for broader context.

Common Problems: Ford F-150

The 10-speed automatic transmission
The 10-speed automatic, introduced in 2017, is the F-150’s most complained-about component. Owners report harsh shifting, gear hunting, delayed engagement, and sudden drops to first gear at highway speed. Most seriously, some trucks have rolled away while the shifter showed Park. NHTSA data shows 28 crash-linked powertrain complaints for the F-150, versus 11 for the Silverado, and a full transmission replacement typically costs $4,500 to $6,000. Ford refined the calibration from 2020 onward, with significantly fewer complaints from that year forward — but if you are buying a 2017–2019 F-150, drive it long enough to feel every shift, and confirm it holds in Park on a slope.
Cam phasers, EcoBoost turbos, and electronics
Cam phasers — the components that control variable valve timing — are a known weak point on the 5.0-liter V8 and the 3.5-liter EcoBoost, announcing themselves with a rattling noise on cold starts. Repair costs typically run $1,500 to $4,000, so listen for the rattle before you buy any used F-150. The early 3.5-liter EcoBoost engines (2011–2016) had the most serious problems: timing chain stretch, turbocharger failures, and premature bearing wear. A turbo failure can cost $2,500 to $5,500 for both turbos, and timing-chain damage can run $2,000 to $10,000. The second-generation 3.5-liter EcoBoost from 2017 onward is better, and the 2.7-liter EcoBoost has a stronger record, but turbos remain a wear item a naturally aspirated V8 does not have. Current-generation owners also report SYNC 4 infotainment freezes, backup camera failures, and instrument cluster glitches — annoying, but the kind of problems that send a truck to the dealer repeatedly.
Common Problems: Chevy Silverado 1500
The Silverado’s problems are fewer in number but can be more expensive when they hit — because its biggest issue strikes the engine itself.

AFM and DFM lifter failure
This is the Silverado problem every buyer needs to understand. Active Fuel Management (AFM), and its successor Dynamic Fuel Management (DFM) from 2019 onward, shut down cylinders under light load to save fuel. The collapsible lifters that make this possible wear prematurely, stick, and collapse — producing a loud ticking from the engine, misfires, and oil consumption, sometimes a quart every 1,000 to 2,000 miles. Left unchecked, a collapsed lifter scores the camshaft and sends metal debris through the engine. Lifter and camshaft repairs commonly cost $2,500 to $4,000, rising to $8,000 if the damage is caught late, and a remanufactured engine typically runs $5,000 to $9,000 installed. The problem affects 5.3-liter and 6.2-liter V8s from 2007 onward, and DFM reduced it rather than eliminating it. The 4.3-liter V6 has no cylinder deactivation and sidesteps the issue entirely, and the 3.0-liter Duramax diesel is a separate, well-regarded engine.
8-speed shudder and the 6.2-liter recall
Silverado 1500s from 2015–2019 with the 8-speed automatic suffer a well-documented shudder, along with harsh shifts. Fluid flushes and software updates help some trucks; others need repairs costing $2,000 to $3,500 or more. In 2025, GM issued recall campaign N252494001 covering about 600,000 vehicles — including 2021–2024 Silverado 1500s with the 6.2-liter L87 V8 — for a connecting rod and crankshaft defect that can cause sudden engine failure, so check the VIN and confirm the fix was performed before you buy. Consumer Reports also notes owner reports of electrical problems on recent Silverados, including lights, gauges, USB ports, and automatic headlights.
Recalls and Complaints Compared
Recall counts are a blunt tool, but across nine model years they show a consistent pattern. Federal recall records for 2018–2026 show 107 recalls for the F-150 versus 91 for the Silverado, and owner complaints run 5.4 per 10,000 F-150s sold against 3.8 per 10,000 Silverados.
The Silverado beats or ties the F-150 in six of the nine model years tracked. The F-150’s weakest years were 2018 (1,852 complaints) and 2021 (1,021 complaints, 26 recalls); the Silverado’s weakest were 2019 (1,043 complaints) and 2021 (720 complaints). Both trucks’ newest models look strong, but the 2026 models have had little time to collect complaints, so treat those scores as promising rather than proven.
Repair and Maintenance Costs
RepairPal gives both trucks the same reliability rating — 3.5 out of 5 — but ranks the Silverado fifth among full-size trucks and the F-150 seventh. The cost gap is small but consistent: about $714 a year for the Silverado, versus about $788 for the F-150.
Both trucks carry identical warranty coverage: 3 years or 36,000 miles basic, and 5 years or 60,000 miles powertrain. The Silverado includes a complimentary first oil change and tire rotation; the F-150 does not include free scheduled maintenance.
Two cost warnings apply to both trucks once they pass 60,000 miles and leave warranty behind. Independent owner guides put annual repair costs at $1,100 to $1,800 for older examples of either truck, and the big failures are expensive on both sides: a transmission replacement on the F-150 can exceed $5,000, and an engine rebuild on a Silverado with lifter damage can reach $8,000.
Still comparing? See the Toyota Corolla vs Honda Civic matchup for a sedan take on this kind of head-to-head, or the Toyota RAV4 vs Mazda CX-5 guide for a compact-SUV comparison.
Best and Worst Model Years to Buy
If you are buying used, the model year matters more than the brand:
| Ford F-150 | Chevy Silverado 1500 | |
|---|---|---|
| Best bets | 2020, 2023, 2024 | 2023, 2024, 2025 |
| Years to avoid | 2011, 2012 (early EcoBoost), 2018 (10-speed), 2021 (first year of current generation) | 2007–2013 (AFM lifters), 2019 (first year of current generation, DFM lifters), 2021 (DFM lifters, weak year) |
Avoid the first year of a new generation, and the first years of a new engine or transmission. The 2023 Silverado (75/100) and the 2024 F-150 (74/100) are the strongest shared model years with at least two years on the road.
Which Engine Is the Most Reliable?
Engine choice is where the reliability decision is actually made, because the two lineups take opposite approaches. Ford bets on turbocharging; Chevrolet sticks with big naturally aspirated V8s.
Most reliable F-150 engine: the 5.0-liter Coyote V8. Consumer Reports calls it a solid and reliable motor, and it is the simplest engine in Ford’s lineup — no turbos, no hybrid system. The 2.7-liter EcoBoost is the next-best bet. The 3.5-liter EcoBoost is powerful but carries the cam phaser and turbo history. The PowerBoost hybrid is Consumer Reports’ top-rated full-size truck for predicted reliability.

Most reliable Silverado engine: the 5.3-liter V8 — with a caveat. It has a decades-long track record and well-maintained examples routinely pass 200,000 miles, but the AFM/DFM lifter issue applies to it, so service history and oil-change discipline matter enormously. The 3.0-liter Duramax turbodiesel earns high marks for efficiency and durability and avoids the lifter problem entirely. The 6.2-liter V8 is the one to be careful with: strong and smooth, but it carries the 2021–2024 recall, so verify the fix or choose another year. The broader lesson: stick to lower trims with fewer electronic gadgets, and nothing beats a good old V8 for years of trouble-free motoring. Compare the two side by side with our Compare Cars tool.
Buying Used? Run This Checklist
These checks catch the expensive problems before you sign:
- Check the VIN for open recalls. Free on NHTSA’s website. On a 2021–2024 Silverado 6.2L, confirm the engine recall fix is done.
- Cold-start the engine and listen. Cam phaser rattle on an F-150 and lifter tick on a Silverado both show up best on a cold start. Walk away from a seller who has the truck warmed up when you arrive.
- Drive the transmission through every gear. On the F-150, feel for harsh shifts and gear hunting. On a 2015–2019 Silverado, feel for the 8-speed shudder under light acceleration.
- Park on a slope and test Park. The F-150 rollaway issue is rare but serious — the truck must hold firmly in Park.
- Check the oil and ask for service records. Heavy oil consumption is a warning sign on both trucks, and low oil on a Silverado V8 can point to lifter trouble. Regular oil changes are the single best predictor of whether either truck’s engine will last.
- Get a pre-purchase inspection. A mechanic will spot lifter noise, transmission wear, and frame rust that a test drive will not.
See also our Toyota Tacoma vs Ford Ranger comparison, Chevrolet Colorado vs Ford Ranger comparison, and best cars for college students guide.
Verdict: Which Truck Is More Reliable?
The Chevrolet Silverado 1500 wins on reliability — narrowly. It takes J.D. Power’s dependability study, has fewer recalls and complaints per truck sold, costs a little less to repair, and has a slightly better chance of reaching 250,000 miles. Its naturally aspirated V8s have a longer, simpler track record than Ford’s turbocharged engines.
Two qualifications: for a brand-new 2026 truck, J.D. Power scores the two identically at 86/100, and Consumer Reports rates the F-150 higher for 2026, naming it a Top Pick with the PowerBoost hybrid its most reliable full-size truck.
So here is the practical answer:

- Buy the Silverado 1500 if you plan to keep the truck for 10 years or 200,000 miles, you want the simplest proven engine (the 5.3-liter V8 or the 3.0-liter diesel), or you are buying used and want the lower complaint and recall load. Avoid 2019 and 2021, and verify the 6.2-liter recall fix on 2021–2024 trucks.
- Buy the Ford F-150 if you are buying new (the 2026 trucks are tied on J.D. Power and the F-150 wins on Consumer Reports), you want the PowerBoost hybrid, or you prefer the 5.0-liter V8. Avoid 2011, 2012, 2018, and 2021, and test the 10-speed transmission thoroughly on any used example.
- Either way, pick the right engine and model year, demand service records, and get a pre-purchase inspection. Those three decisions matter more than the badge on the grille.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which is more reliable, the Ford F-150 or the Chevy Silverado?
The Chevrolet Silverado 1500, narrowly. It ranked highest in its segment in J.D. Power’s 2025 Vehicle Dependability Study and second in the 2026 study, while the F-150 tied for third, and it has fewer recalls and fewer complaints per truck sold. For brand-new 2026 trucks, the two tie at 86 out of 100 from J.D. Power.
What does Consumer Reports say about F-150 vs Silverado reliability?
Consumer Reports gives the 2026 Ford F-150 a predicted reliability score of 43 out of 100, slightly ahead of the 2026 Chevrolet Silverado 1500 at 40 out of 100. The F-150 PowerBoost hybrid scores higher still at 49 out of 100, the most reliable full-size truck in Consumer Reports’ 2026 data, and the F-150 earned a Consumer Reports Top Pick for 2026.
How long will a Ford F-150 or Chevy Silverado last?
Both can pass 200,000 miles with regular maintenance, and many owners report 250,000 miles or more. According to iSeeCars’ analysis of over 402 million vehicles, the Silverado 1500 has an 18.8% chance of reaching 250,000 miles, compared with 15.8% for the Ford F-150 — both well above the 8.6% average for all vehicles.
What are the most common problems with the Ford F-150?
The F-150’s most reported problems are its 10-speed automatic transmission (harsh shifting, gear hunting, and in some cases trucks rolling away while showing Park), cam phaser rattle on the 5.0-liter V8 and 3.5-liter EcoBoost, and turbo and timing-chain trouble on early 3.5-liter EcoBoost engines. A 10-speed transmission replacement can cost $4,500 to $6,000.
What are the most common problems with the Chevy Silverado 1500?
The Silverado’s biggest problem is lifter failure in its 5.3-liter and 6.2-liter V8 engines, caused by the Active Fuel Management and Dynamic Fuel Management cylinder-deactivation systems. A collapsed lifter can damage the camshaft, with repairs commonly costing $2,500 to $4,000 and up to $8,000 if caught late. Other issues include 8-speed shudder on 2015–2019 trucks and a recall covering about 600,000 GM vehicles with the 2021–2024 6.2-liter V8.
Which truck is cheaper to repair, the F-150 or the Silverado?
The Silverado is slightly cheaper to keep on the road. RepairPal puts the Silverado’s average annual repair cost at about $714, versus about $788 for the F-150; both earn 3.5 out of 5 from RepairPal. Both trucks carry the same warranty: 3 years or 36,000 miles basic and 5 years or 60,000 miles powertrain.
More head-to-heads on the site: Honda Pilot vs Toyota Highlander and Jeep Wrangler vs Ford Bronco.
